Martindale Awards

Peer av2021-rating-full.png

AV Preeminent®: The highest peer rating standard. This rating signifies that a large number of the lawyer’s peers rank him or her at the highest level of professional excellence for their legal knowledge, communication skills and ethical standards.

Client Client Champion

Client Champion Platinum is awarded to lawyers/firms with at least 10 reviews, with an average score of 4.5 or higher.

Martindale Ratings

Average Peer Rating
4.4/5.0
Average Client Rating
Client Recommended
100% client recommended

Reviews (84)

Sort by:
5.0/5.0

Scott was straight to the point, no sugar coating anything! He won't waste your time and has sound advice that helped steer our family in making the correct decision with the best financial integrity and gain...

Read More

Client 2021/03/18

5.0/5.0

I made the mistake of trying to start an LLC using online resources. What I quickly found out they had no customer service. I had questions, and decided to contacted Scott and I am sure glad I did, now I am back on...

Read More

Client 2021/03/10

5.0/5.0

Scott Anthony McMillan consulted with me on a dispute I was involved in! His consulting was spot on! I would highly recommend him. He was VERY forthcoming and willing to lead me in the right direction.

Read More

Client 2021/01/21

5.0/5.0

Helped me very much without even charging me. Spent quite a while on the phone with me. He is patient and I can tell that when the time comes he can be as tough as nails. Thanks

Read More

Client 2020/10/16

5.0/5.0

He was very informative and helpful and kind he gets into my situation with full attention had all my answers gave me several options that I have and its pricing is very very reasonable

Read More

Client 2020/06/24

5.0/5.0

Mr. McMillan was amazingly helpful in helping me battle an insurance company that sued me for $70,000. Mr. McMillan put in an incredible amount of time and was generous about not nickel and diming me for issues...

Read More

Client 2019/07/23

5.0/5.0

Scott has a rare combination in the legal profession of skill, integrity, wisdom and compassion. I called him with a contract question, and was willing to pay for his time. He generously offered me a gratis 10...

Read More

Client 2019/01/11

5.0/5.0

I called about a contract issue and he was most helpful, without hesitation and lead me right to the civil code to protect me and my issue. Was very pleasant to talk to and understand. I would absolutely hire him...

Read More

Client 2018/11/28

5.0/5.0

I have known Scott McMillan as an attorney for over a decade. He has shown the highest quality in terms of knowledge of the law, representation of his clients and advocacy on behalf of his clients.

Read More

Attorney 2018/10/23

5.0/5.0

I had a question about a case I’ve been involved in and Scott understood the situation immediately and gave a quick run down of my options.

Read More

Client 2018/10/14

5.0/5.0

While he couldn’t help with my issues he gave me great advice in a very tough yet sincere manner.

Read More

Client 2018/09/03

5.0/5.0

Called Mr. McMillan re: horses boarded on my ranch without pay. He knew the codes, gave me a solution, suggested another way to increase my income, and told me to go for it! Then he recommended another attorney in...

Read More

Client 2018/06/19

5.0/5.0

He was able to answer all my questions in a way that I understood perfectly and was very helpful in easing the stress I was having related to the situation. He was very responsive and I felt like I finally had...

Read More

Client 2017/10/29

5.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Attorney 2017/10/06

5.0/5.0

Scott McMillan has helped me every step of the way on multiple cases! I highly recommend McMillan Law Firm for anyone who needs a professional, knowledgeable, and hard working attorney. Scott is upfront and gets...

Read More

Client 2017/07/29

5.0/5.0

I was having so much trouble finding a lawyer that was willing to take on my case. I had gone through two lawyers and they took my money but did nothing for me. I got in contact with Scott through a friend's...

Read More

Client 2017/07/28

5.0/5.0

Scott took his time to hear my questions on how to approach a Partnership dissolution that was getting out of hand. He was attentive and offered a variety of solutions that I needed to make a clear decision. ( I...

Read More

Client 2017/07/13

5.0/5.0

I hired Scott to handle a breach of contract issue. I had consulted with four other attorneys before meeting Scott. After months of preparation and a week-long trial, we walked out of court with a judgment close to...

Read More

Client 2017/06/15

5.0/5.0

Scott is unique in his practice as his legal knowledge is both a mile wide and a mile deep. This allows him to think laterally in his problem solving for clients and thread the needle on very nuanced areas of law.

Read More

Managing Partner 2017/02/13

5.0/5.0

Mr. Scott McMillan possess excellent analytical and reasoning skills. I confidently refer my clients to Mr. McMillan for assistance. Mr. McMillan excels at protecting clients interest in protracted complex civil...

Read More

Associate 2017/02/13

5.0/5.0

Mr. McMillan is an exceptional attorney. He is creative, dedicated and constantly fighting for his client's rights. He holds high ethical standards without compromising relentless representation.

Read More

Partner 2017/02/12

5.0/5.0

Scott is one of the most hardworking, tenacious and ethical lawyers I have had the pleasure of working with. He fights hard, but fair. Scott's wealth of knowledge and experience ensures that his clients receive the...

Read More

Sole Practitioner 2017/02/11

5.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Sole Practitioner 2017/02/10

5.0/5.0

Scott is an excellent practitioner, combining his knowledge with practical and pragmatic problem solving approaches. He is also very communicative with his clients and other attorneys.

Read More

Sole Practitioner 2017/02/06

5.0/5.0

Mr. McMillan helped me with an issue surrounding a potential mechanics lien claim on my house. He researched contractors state licensing acts and business and professional code regulations and found compliance...

Read More

Client 2017/02/06

5.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Senior Associate 2017/02/06

5.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Associate 2017/02/04

5.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Associate 2017/02/04

5.0/5.0

Scott McMillan helped me navigate a very unfamiliar course involving a case against a former employer and he exceeded my expectations while doing so. During our regular progress calls he explained what was...

Read More

Client 2016/07/18

5.0/5.0

Scott has been my attorney on several matters. I first hired him in 2013 and over the past 3 years I have spent a lot of time with him, giving me the opportunity to get to know him very well. I can not speak highly...

Read More

Client 2016/04/22

5.0/5.0

I was involved in a property dispute that quickly turned into nightmare and left me stressed and in despair. I was in need of legal help when I went to meet Scott and asked him to represent me. From the...

Read More

Client 2014/03/03

5.0/5.0

I was involved in a property dispute that quickly turned into nightmare and left me stressed and in despair. I was in need of legal help when I went to meet Scott and asked him to represent me. From the...

Read More

Client 2014/03/03

5.0/5.0

I worked with Scott for two years as a litigation associate and can say without reservation that it is unlikely you will find an attorney as tenacious and honest to advance or defend your interests. His reputation...

Read More

Client 2013/12/13

5.0/5.0

You will not be disappointed with Scott and his firm. He won a case for me that made news on many websites. He was honest and kept me in the loop. He never tired of my constant questions and answered them promptly...

Read More

Client 2013/08/06

5.0/5.0

I met Scott and Evan while serving on a jury in San Diego. Because of the way I witnessed how Scott and Kevin handled the case, when I needed some legal advice on an employment law issue I turned to Scott. He...

Read More

Client 2012/12/29

5.0/5.0

I met Scott while serving on a jury. Based on this, when I needed legal advice on an employment law issue I turned to Scott. He worked with me to understand the case, what my rights are and what actions where...

Read More

Client 2012/12/28

5.0/5.0

Heartfelt and humbled, I am so grateful and appreciative of their legal expertise. Scott McMillan, Evan Kalooky, and the staff of the McMillan Law Firm for setting the record straight against the plaintiff(s)...

Read More

Client 2012/12/23

5.0/5.0

Scott McMillan has very successfully represented me over the past year and a half, both in fighting a large and complex bankruptcy where I'm an unsecured creditor and in defending me in civil litigation. He is...

Read More

Client 2012/06/03

5.0/5.0

Mr. McMillan always responds immediately to my inquiries, he's honest and straight-forward, and extremely tenacious in dealing with the games of other lawyers. The two other attorneys in his office, Evan Kalooky...

Read More

Client 2012/05/28

5.0/5.0

I found Scott McMillan online. The McMillan Law Firm expressed familiarity with my questions and in the area that I needed help in. Scott McMillan was as portrayed on the website, so I hired him to help me. Over...

Read More

Client 2012/03/23

5.0/5.0

I found Scott and his staff to be very professional, courteous, knowledgeable, and comfortable in the courtroom. They use their resources to prepare for excellent representation of the client in all settings.

Read More

Client 2012/01/30

5.0/5.0

Scott and his staff are professional, courteous, knowledgeable, well versed in the law, and at home in the courtroom. They give 100 percent of their efforts to helping their clients. I recommend them to any who...

Read More

Client 2012/01/30

5.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Managing Partner 2011/10/02

5.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Sole Practitioner 2011/08/24

5.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Partner 2011/08/20

5.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Principal 2011/08/19

5.0/5.0

Because of Scott, I survived a legal nightmare. His skill and unflagging determination to provide relief carried me through some dark days. His integrity is beyond reproach as he advocates for his clients, no...

Read More

Client 2011/08/09

5.0/5.0

We hired Scott McMillan (and his associates) to represent our bond positions in various complex corporate bankruptcies. In the proceedings Scott was extremely persistent in making sure our voice was heard. ...

Read More

Client 2011/08/08

5.0/5.0

Scott some years ago praised me on Linked-in after a case on which we both worked. He did a fine job on that case. Our firm works with him on several matters. He's an excellent lawyer. If I needed one in his...

Read More

Of Counsel 2011/08/04

5.0/5.0

Scott is an experienced and very talented lawyer who is able to guide clients through complex and technical litigation and negotiations. He is well-known for being driven and outcome orientated in his approach and...

Read More

Client 2011/07/16

5.0/5.0

Scott and his legal team were truly amazing. They were passionate about my case, responsive to my questions/concerns, and did not break the bank. In fact, Scott encouraged me to help out with administrative work...

Read More

Client 2011/07/14

5.0/5.0

Scott and his staff were a great team to have in my corner. They were professional, responsive and did not nickel and dime me. Most importantly, Scott not only got the result I wanted, he researched the case and...

Read More

Client 2011/07/14

5.0/5.0

Because of Scott, I survived a legal nightmare. His skill and unflagging determination to provide relief carried me through some pretty dark days. His integrity is beyond reproach as he advocates for his clients,...

Read More

Client 2011/07/02

5.0/5.0

I was recently involved in a civil case as the plaintiff and hired Scott to represent me. Scott is not like all the other money-hungry attorneys out there. He is extremely dedicated to winning your case,...

Read More

Client 2010/04/14

5.0/5.0

The McMillan law firm is top notch. I drove down from Los Angeles to Mesa with a lot of questions and a huge employment mess in my hands. I met with an amazing man that really cared about the outcome of my case. He...

Read More

Client 2009/12/19

5.0/5.0

He is competent and professional.

Read More

Other Legal Professional 2009/11/24

5.0/5.0

this guy is totally committed to you and your case. he assigns you a young gun (attorney) to keep you updated and your very well taken care of.the hourly rate for the young guns is very reasonable and thier...

Read More

Client 2007/07/25

5.0/5.0

A Street-Smart, tough, and legally astute lawyer. If you have a mess on your hands, Scott will fight for you.

Read More

Client 2007/07/24

5.0/5.0

While our family was engaged in a property dispute with a government entity, for months, our former attorney was getting us nowhere fast on our court case. With only a family budget and such a large government...

Read More

Client 2007/07/21

4.8/5.0

Scott combines trial lawyer instincts with state of the art evidence presentation. He is a tireless advocate for his clients. He uses the internet to educate others, and works with civil rights and class action...

Read More

Sole Practitioner 2017/02/12

4.8/5.0

Mr. McMillan is a very capable and well respected attorney.

Read More

Sole Practitioner 2011/08/15

4.8/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Member 2009/11/23

4.8/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Member 2009/11/23

4.6/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Senior Associate 2011/08/03

4.6/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Associate 2009/11/09

4.4/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Senior Associate 2017/02/16

4.4/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Partner 2017/02/12

4.4/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Managing Partner 2009/11/06

4.2/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Partner 2017/02/12

4.2/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Associate 2014/12/13

4.0/5.0

I appreciated Scott's view of the potential case. His very first comment was about his billing rate (as was his last comment) Perhaps Scott can consider softening because we all know lawyers have a fee and Scott...

Read More

Client 2017/04/20

4.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Sole Practitioner 2017/02/07

4.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Managing Partner 2009/11/23

4.0/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Partner 2009/08/20

4.0/5.0

Scott is hardworking and is VERY dedicated to his clients. He keeps you informed and will truly put your best interest first. He is easy to talk to and will listen to you when you speak to him. To Scott you are not...

Read More

Client 2007/07/21

3.8/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Partner 2011/08/19

3.8/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Associate 2009/11/15

3.6/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Judge 2011/09/28

3.6/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Principal 2011/09/01

3.6/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Judge 2011/08/15

3.4/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Associate 2017/02/06

3.4/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Other Law Firm Position 2009/12/04

3.2/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Partner 2011/08/20

1.8/5.0

No description provided

Read More

Managing Partner 2015/12/20